At a Small Company, the CEO Is the Hiring Manager
Under about a hundred employees there's usually no recruiting team, no vendor list and no gatekeeper with a policy. There's an owner, a president or a general manager who signs the checks and makes the call. That makes small companies fast, loyal and a little fee-nervous, all at once.
- At most companies under about 100 people, the owner, president or general manager owns every req, or one lone department leader does.
- You can usually tell company size from the ad itself: how it's written, who the role reports to, how people apply and what benefits it lists.
- Owners think about three things: cash, their own time and the risk of a bad hire. Pitch all three, in that language.
- Fee sensitivity is real but it's about the size of the check, not your value; handle it with terms, not discounts.
- Your first placement at a small company is an audition for the next ten; run it like one.
Why the small end of the market is worth your desk
Most employers in the U.S. are small. Using Census Bureau survey data for 2021, Pew Research Center found that among roughly 6 million small businesses with employees, 49% had one to four workers, 27% had five to 19, and 8% had 20 to 99. The count is growing, too: the Census Bureau reported 5.52 million employer firms with fewer than 500 employees in 2022, up from 5.38 million in 2021. Put differently, the companies most agency recruiters ignore are the ones that make up most of the market.
The one-to-four group mostly can't afford a fee and doesn't hire often. The sweet spot is roughly 20 to 100 employees: big enough to have real roles (a controller, an IT manager, an operations lead) and to pay for them, small enough that nobody in the building is paid to keep agencies out. There is no talent acquisition team scoring you on cost-per-hire. There's a person who needs a seat filled and has to approve the invoice personally.
That changes the whole sale. At a large employer you're fighting a process. At a small one you're having a business conversation with the person who owns the problem, which is why the usual advice to skip HR and find the req owner is almost automatic here: often there's no HR to skip.
How to tell the company's size from the ad
Read the ad before you look anything else up. Small companies write ads differently from large ones, and the differences tell you who to ask for.| Clue in the ad | What it usually means | Who to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| "Reports directly to the owner" or "to the President" | Owner-run, almost always under 100 people | The owner, by name |
| "Wear many hats," "small, close-knit team," "family-owned since 1987" | Small, often under 50, often second-generation | The owner or the GM who runs day to day |
| Apply by emailing a person, or a short form instead of a big applicant system | No dedicated recruiting function | Whoever's name is on the email address |
| One location, a street address, "join our growing team of 30" | A single-site business that told you its headcount | Owner or GM; at 30-plus, maybe the department leader |
| Generic benefits ("competitive pay, PTO, health") with no long benefits list | No HR department writing ads | The owner or office manager who wrote it |
| A role that does three jobs: "bookkeeper / office manager / HR" | The company is too small to split them; the owner is overloaded | The owner, and lead with time saved |
| Polished employer brand, long legal footer, many openings across states | Larger company or a subsidiary of one | Department leader; this isn't a small-company call |
The owner, or the one leader who runs the function
At a small company the req belongs to one of two people.
The owner, president or general manager owns anything without a department head over it: the first office manager, the first operations hire, the first salesperson, a general manager to take day-to-day off the owner's plate. They also approve every salaried hire even when someone else does the interviewing.
The lone department leader owns everything under them. A 60-person distributor has one controller, and that controller is the hiring manager for the staff accountant, the AP clerk and the bookkeeper. A company with a single IT manager has its desktop support hire made by that one person, who is also doing the job until the seat is filled. Treat that lone leader as you would the owner: they have the authority, they feel the pain directly, and they usually have the owner's ear on the fee.
One wrinkle on IT: many small companies don't employ IT people at all. They outsource the whole function to a managed IT provider, and those providers hire the desktop support and help-desk techs themselves. If a 25-person company has no IT ad, its IT provider might; see our post on IT managed-service firms as employers.
When owners pick up their own phone
At a small company, the main line is your best number. Here's when the person you want is most likely to answer it.The owner answers the main line
You called about a staff accountant ad at a 45-person company and the president picked up. Speak to cash, time and risk, and skip the agency pitch.Fee sensitivity, and how to handle it without discounting
An owner looking at a five-figure invoice isn't comparing it to a recruiting budget. They're comparing it to a truck payment, a month of rent or their own take-home pay. That's why the fee conversation at a small company sounds more emotional than at a large one. It's personal money.
Handle it with structure, not with a lower number:
- Talk in dollars and outcomes. "The fee on a $60,000 hire is X, due 30 days after start, and it's covered by a guarantee" is easier to say yes to than a percentage on a long contract.
- Offer terms, not discounts. Net-30 after the start date, or a split payment, costs you little and solves the owner's real problem, which is cash flow.
- Trade any fee movement for something. Exclusivity, a fast interview schedule, or a second search. The full approach is in our post on how to defend your fee without discounting.
- Keep the agreement short and plain. A two-page document in plain English beats a twelve-page contract an owner has to send to a lawyer. Lawyers cost money and slow everything down.
The office manager who wasn't the job
A solo recruiter in Indianapolis called a 30-person HVAC contractor about an office manager ad. The owner, Dale, wanted someone to run the front office, handle AP, do some HR paperwork and dispatch on Fridays. He'd interviewed eight people and liked none of them.
Instead of sending more resumes, the recruiter asked Dale to walk through his week. The real problem came out in ten minutes: Dale was doing the books himself at night, and he'd stuffed that work into the office manager job because he didn't think he could afford two hires. The recruiter suggested splitting it: a full-charge bookkeeper now, and a lighter front-office role later. Dale hired the bookkeeper three weeks later, paid the fee without a word, and called back in the spring about the front desk himself.
That's the small-company version of a req intake. The owner often has the wrong job description because nobody has ever helped them write one. Fixing it is worth more to them than any candidate you could have sent for the original ad.
Running your first placement at a small company
The first hire decides whether you become the owner's recruiter or a bad story they tell the next agency.- Send two or three candidates, each with a short note on why. Owners don't have time for a stack, and a stack says you didn't screen.
- Put the fee, the payment date and the guarantee on one page and walk through it on the phone before you send it.
- Offer to set up the interviews yourself. Owners often have no one to do that and will lose candidates to scheduling.
- Prepare the candidate for a small company: they'll meet the owner, the job will blur at the edges, and decisions are fast. Candidates from large companies need to hear that.
- Call the owner the day after the start, at two weeks and at 60 days. Small companies can't hide a bad fit for long; you want to hear about it first.
- Ask, once the hire is working, who else in the business is stretched thin. At a small company, one placement shows you every other seat.
- Send the invoice exactly when you said you would, and thank them when it's paid. Owners notice who keeps their word on money.
Questions agency recruiters ask
- Is it okay to call the CEO directly at a small company?
Yes. Under about 100 people, the owner or president is often the hiring manager or the final approver, and many answer their own phone. Be brief, name the open role, and ask whether they or a department leader is running the search.
- Small companies say they can't afford agency fees. Should I lower mine?
Usually not. The objection is about cash flow and risk, not your value. Offer payment terms, a clear guarantee and a short agreement first. If you move the fee at all, trade it for exclusivity or a second search.
- Which roles do small companies actually pay fees for?
The ones they can't fill by word of mouth: controllers and full-charge bookkeepers, IT managers, operations and general managers, experienced salespeople, and skilled technical roles. Entry-level admin roles they'll usually fill themselves.
- How do I find out how big a company is before I call?
Start with the ad: who the role reports to, how people apply and how the company describes itself. Then just ask on the call. "How big is the team now?" is a normal question that owners are usually proud to answer.
